Thermostatic vs. Pressure Balance Shower Valves: Pros and Cons

In modern bathrooms, many options are available for upgrading your shower experience. Among the choices, you may find yourself making a common comparison: thermostatic vs. pressure balance valves. Understanding the differences between these two systems is crucial for anyone looking to renovate or install a new shower. Let’s delve into what each valve is, how they function, and the pros and cons of each to help you make an informed decision.
 
 

Thermostatic Shower Valves

What are They?

The design of thermostatic shower valves enables them to maintain a consistent water temperature, regardless of fluctuations in water pressure or temperature elsewhere in the plumbing system.
 
 

How Do They Function?

A cartridge specifically engineered to regulate the water temperature is inside a thermostatic valve. This cartridge reacts to changes in the temperature of the incoming hot and cold water. It adjusts the mix accordingly to maintain the set temperature.
 
The thermostatic valve operates on the principle of thermal expansion. When you adjust the temperature setting on the valve, it alters the position of the cartridge inside. This cartridge typically contains two chambers: one for hot water and one for cold water. Turning the temperature control handle adjusts the size of each chamber’s opening to allow more or less hot and cold water to mix.
 
 

Temperature Regulation and Safety

When the water temperature from either the hot or cold supply changes, the thermostatic element within the cartridge expands or contracts accordingly. This movement controls the position of the cartridge, ensuring that the mix of hot and cold water remains consistent to achieve the desired temperature setting.
 
Additionally, many thermostatic valves incorporate safety features such as anti-scald protection. This feature monitors the temperature of the mixed water. It can automatically shut off the flow if it exceeds a preset limit, preventing scalding accidents.
 
 

Pros of Thermostatic Shower Valves

• Precise Temperature Control: Thermostatic valves allow you to set a specific water temperature and maintain it throughout your shower, regardless of fluctuations in water supply or pressure.

 

• Safety: Thermostatic valves often come with anti-scald features, which prevent the water from reaching dangerously hot temperatures, making them safer, especially for households with children or elderly individuals.

 

• Comfort: Once set, thermostatic valves provide a consistent and comfortable showering experience, maintaining the desired temperature without requiring constant adjustments.

 

• Customization: Many thermostatic valves have additional features such as volume controls, diverters, and even digital displays like Kohler’s Anthem for enhanced customization and control.

Cons of Thermostatic Valves

• Cost: Thermostatic valves tend to be more expensive than pressure balance valves in terms of the initial purchase and potential maintenance or repair costs.

 

• Complexity: The additional features and mechanisms in thermostatic valves can make them more complex to install and maintain, requiring professional installation in some cases.

Pressure Balance Shower Valves

What are They?

Pressure balance shower valves are more straightforward in design but equally effective in ensuring a comfortable shower experience. These valves balance hot and cold water pressures to prevent sudden temperature changes.
 
 

How Do They Function?

A pressure balance valve typically contains a single cartridge with a diaphragm or piston mechanism. When there’s a drop in the pressure of one water supply (hot or cold), the valve adjusts to compensate and maintain a consistent ratio between hot and cold water.
 
The mechanism inside a pressure balance valve maintains the ratio of hot to cold water based on the position of the handle. When you adjust the handle to increase or decrease the temperature, the valve responds by adjusting the hot and cold water flow to maintain the desired temperature ratio.
 
 

Pros of Pressure Balance Shower Valves

• Affordable: Pressure balance valves are typically more budget-friendly than thermostatic valves, making them a cost-effective option for many households.

 

• Simple Operation: Pressure balance valves are easy to operate, with a single handle controlling temperature and pressure. This simplicity can be advantageous for users who prefer a more intuitive interface.

 

• Reliability: Pressure balance valves are known for their durability and reliability, requiring minimal maintenance.

 
 

Cons of Pressure Balance Shower Valves

• Temperature Fluctuations: While pressure balance valves can maintain consistent pressure, they do not offer the same level of temperature stability as thermostatic valves. This instability can lead to fluctuations in water temperature, mainly if other appliances or fixtures are using water simultaneously.

 

• Limited Temperature Control: Pressure balance valves do not provide the same precise temperature control as thermostatic valves. This characteristic can be a drawback for users who prefer a specific water temperature.

Making the Right Choice

When comparing, thermostatic vs. pressure balance shower valves, it’s important to consider your needs and priorities. A thermostatic valve might be worthwhile if precise temperature control and safety features are paramount. On the other hand, if you’re looking for a more uncomplicated and more budget-friendly option that still provides reliable temperature regulation, a pressure balance valve could be the way to go.
 
Ultimately, both types of valves have their advantages and limitations. By understanding how each works and weighing the pros and cons of thermostatic vs. pressure balance, you can make an educated decision that suits your preferences and budget for a satisfying shower experience every time. If you still have questions about which valve is best for you, don’t hesitate to contact our team. We’ll be happy to guide you further to make an informed decision.
 
 

Our Promise

At Borhn, we believe in putting power back in the hands of consumers. Our thermostatic and pressure balance shower sets aren’t just products. They’re a targeted response to the markups enforced by middlemen in the bathroom industry. We’ve meticulously crafted these sets with you in mind, ensuring top-notch quality without the outrageous price tags. We’re not just offering you a product by cutting out the unnecessary layers of middlemen. We’re offering you a revolution in affordability and transparency. Say goodbye to inflated prices and hello to showers that refresh both your body and your wallet. Join us in reshaping the industry, one fair deal at a time.
 
 
 
Icons sourced from www.flaticon.com